Google's Motorola issues second appeal of dismissed ITC case against Apple

Google's Motorola issues second appeal of dismissed ITC case against AppleGet the lowest prices anywhere on Macs and iPads with exclusive coupons: Apple Price Guide updated May 25th. (Get the lowest prices anywhere) HomeReviewsBackpagePrice GuidesNew MacsMacs with AppleCarePrevious MacsiPadsApple Wireless DevicesBid on New & Used Apple ProductsFollow UsTwitterFacebookGoogle+RSS Feeds & QriusiPhone AppTip UsSend us a tiptip us anonymouslyContact us by e-mailForumsAAPL: 445.15 ( +3.01 )Never miss an update Follow AppleInsiderFollow @AppleInsider –A+
Friday, May 24, 2013, 07:08 pm

Google's Motorola issues second appeal of dismissed ITC case against AppleBy Mikey Campbell

Motorola has given notice to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit that it will be contesting the International Trade Commission's dismissal of a case against Apple, the second time the now Google-owned company has filed an appeal tied to that investigation.


The appeals notice, uncovered by FOSS Patents' Florian Mueller after recently being made public, is in regard to an ITC decision to throw out a case against Apple after finding six Motorola patents-in-suit invalid.

In its dismissal, which was filed a month ago, the trade body found Motorola's last standing patent, a property for an infrared proximity sensor, invalid. The company was asserting U.S. Patent No. 6,246,862 for a "sensor controlled user interface for portable communication device," which covers a system that ignores errant screen touches during a phone call.

As noted by Mueller, Google's latest appeal is the second such action for the ITC investigation. The first came in November 2012, which questioned a decision that cleared Apple of infringing on three patents. The contention from Google resulted in a review of the findings, and that appeal has yet to be resolved.

Mueller pointed out that Apple may want to combine the two appeals, thus saving court resources, but the tactic is likely to fail due to the long span between Google's filings.

Motorola's Second Appeal of ITC Dismissal by Mikey Campbell

Tags:patentsMotorolaGoogleJump to comments (21)Categories:General(function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "//connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);}(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk'));Tweet!function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs"); On Topic: patentsGoogle's Motorola issues second appeal of dismissed ITC case against AppleApple granted patents on push-to-talk, double-sided touch panelApple invention adjusts audio based on a display's orientation, user positioningApple investigating advanced AirPlay system with device-specific UIsSamsung Galaxy S4 & Google Now accused of violating Apple patents for SiriToday's' HeadlinesFoxconn may sell own branded accessories after Apple profits dipApple's iPhone sales tactics in Europe under antitrust investigationRelated ArticlesITC throws out Motorola patent suit against AppleITC to review decision that cleared Apple of infringing on Motorola patentsApple cleared of infringing Motorola patents, avoids U.S. import banApple cleared of infringing on Motorola patent in ITC caseGoogle cites quote from Steve Jobs biography in attempt to win iPhone import banPrevious Comments View Alljohn.b2013/05/24 07:39pm

Clearly, holding a phone against the side of your face was a new and unique idea that had never been thought of prior to this patent...

?

?

Though I'm not really sure why Apple would want to combine Motogoogle's appeals.

frood2013/05/24 08:23pm

Hooray!?? Seeing?more or less trivial patents invalidated never gets old.? The new digital age is less about inventions and more about obstruction.?? Only 939488583738292 more patents related to 'touching' 'shaping' 'looking at' and 'methods for performing "an operation" on a list' to go and maybe our court system can start working on legitimate stuff

ericthehalfbee2013/05/24 08:29pm

Waiting for GG to claim Google never initiates anything.

starbird732013/05/24 08:46pm

Court to Google/Motorola: You lose.

?

Google/Motorola: But, no, we don't.

?

Court to Google/Motorola: Yes, you do.

?

Google/Motorola: But, but, no, we don't.

?

Court to Google/Motorola: Yes, yes you do.

jungmark2013/05/25 12:51am

Do no evil, google.

applesauce0072013/05/25 07:04am

Three strikes and they're out...

suddenly newton2013/05/25 11:09am

LOL More reporting of court paperwork as 'news.'

ankleskater2013/05/25 11:17am

Quote:Originally Posted by starbird73?

Court to Google/Motorola: You lose.

?

Google/Motorola: But, no, we don't.

?

Court to Google/Motorola: Yes, you do.

?

Google/Motorola: But, but, no, we don't.

?

Court to Google/Motorola: Yes, yes you do.

How is that different from what virtually every company does? Appealing is a legal option and most companies, including those you worship, employ that option liberally, frequently and almost automatically. It's absurd, ridiculous, ignorant, hypocritical and unintelligent to mock any company for appealing.

?

Quote:Originally Posted by EricTheHalfBee?

Waiting for GG to claim Google never initiates anything.

This is a fair comment (about Google, not about GG - that part I couldn't care less about). Motorola is part of Google now, and Google did once declare a non-aggression policy on patents. Whether one agrees with Apple's legal actions, their objective is quite clear. This is not true of Google.

ankleskater2013/05/25 11:19am

Quote:Originally Posted by Suddenly Newton?

LOL More reporting of court paperwork as 'news.'

?LOL. More people reading and mocking it. Yet the joke is clearly, squarely on the mocking reader.

jessi2013/05/25 11:25am

I'm glad to see that Patent Troll Google has lost again, but let's not assume that this is a trivial patent simply because the people describing it do so in simple terms.

Multi-touch is a very sophisticated technology, never seen before (despite the claims from idiots who don't know how it works and who always bring up systems working on a different method, such as pushing two wires tougher as if they were "prior art".) ... and deserves to be protected.

Most of these "trivial" patents are not actually trivial. And getting them tried in court IS the way the patent system was designed.

The idea that there's a problem here is asinine-- the only problem is that innovators like Apple can't get timely resolution to these violations, while companies like google skate by.

But it's embarrassing that people would claim that patents stifle innovation-- patents ARE innovation, and the people being "stifled" weren't being innovative, they were being copycats.

If these patents really are trivial they don't stand up in court.

View all commentsLogin to Comment

Have an opinion? Sign Up to share it.

Latest Apple HeadlinesFoxconn may sell own branded accessories after Apple profits dip~2 hours agoApple's iPhone sales tactics in Europe under antitrust investigation~2 hours agoReview: Scosche enters car radio fray with iOS connected controlFREQ~16 hours agoCradle attachment turns Apple's iPhone into handheld biosensor~16 hours agoWorking Apple I fetches $671,400 in German auction~17 hours agomore...

Want to write for AppleInsider? Submit your application now! Lowest Prices Anywhere!ModelPriceYou Save Core i5 MacBook Pros w/ Retina 13" 2.5GHz/8GB/128GB $1,406.48 $292.52 13" 2.5GHz/8GB/256GB $1,479.99 $519.01 13" 2.5GHz/8GB/512GB $1,699.99 $799.01 Core i7 MacBook Pros w/ Retina 13" 2.9GHz/8GB/256GB $1,599.99 $599.01 13" 2.9GHz/8GB/512GB $1,799.99 $899.01 15" 2.3GHz/8GB/256GB $1,899.99 $299.01 15" 2.6GHz/8GB/512GB $2,299.99 $568.01 15" 2.7GHz/16GB/768GB $2,699.99 $499.01 More configurations
Active Forum Topics

147

Editorial: Apple's iOS 7 needs exclusive, distinctive features, not just a flat UI

25

iPad shipments could see first ever year-on-year decline in Q2, analyst says

11

Cook: US-built Mac will be refreshed version of existing product

10

2013 Mac mini Wishlist/iMac wishlist

8

ISLAM WATCHmore... Model WhiteBlack iPad mini (WiFi only) 16GB WiFi $329.99$329.99 32GB WiFi $429.99 $429.99 64GB WiFi $529.99 $529.99 iPad mini (WiFi + 4G)   16GB 4G White $459.99 $459.99 $459.99 32GB 4G White $559.99 $559.99 $559.99 64GB 4G White $659.99 $659.99 $659.99 16GB 4G Black $459.99 $459.99 $459.99 32GB 4G Black $559.99 $559.99 $559.99 64GB 4G Black $659.99 $659.99 $659.99 See more iPad models in our Price GuidesReviewsHot TopicsGeneraliPhoneTaxesiOSGoogleiPadpatentsappsTim CookApp StoreAndroidlawsuitsMapsApple StoreAT&T
Top of pageCopyright ? 2013, AppleInsider.com, Contact UsPrivacy PolicyAdvertise on AppleInsiderDesign: gesamtbild

View the original article here

iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issues

iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issuesLearn some additional steps to troubleshoot burning issues.

Using iTunes for Windows, you can easily "burn" audio, data, and MP3 CDs with most major disc drives, including:

CD-R CD-RW DVD-R/RW DVD+R/RW

Here are a few tips you can try to solve common issues burning discs with iTunes for Windows.

Download and install the latest version of iTunes. See "Can't burn a CD in iTunes for Windows" for basic troubleshooting steps. If you continue to have difficulty, then continue with the additional troubleshooting steps below.">ACUtil.setPOD('us~en'); var articleId = "TS1374"; var ACStaticText = { 'more': '…more', 'less': 'less' };KmLoader.akamaiUrl = 'http://km.support.apple.com';//function sendRead()var locale = 'en_US';Event.observe(window, 'load', function() {ACHistory.addKbView('TS1374', 'iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issues', 'en_US', 'unknown');ACUtil.getMultipleOffers('PP67,PL115', 'TROUBLESHOOTING_ARTICLES', 'en_US', 'false');ACUtil.reportView('TS1374', 'en_US');// Apple Instant Feed statistics code if(enableAppleInstant == "yes"){var store = new Persist.Store('FeedStats');if (store.get('resultActivity')=='true'){var time = new Date();// Fix for /*setReadTimer = setTimeout(function(){var feedStats = new ACFeedStatistics();feedStats.updateRead('TS1374', store.get('position'));store.remove('TS1374');store.remove('position');}, 3000);*///store.set('TS1374', time.getTime());store.set('timeStart', time.getTime());}} });Event.observe(window, 'beforeunload', function(){// Apple Instant Feed statistics code if(enableAppleInstant == "yes"){ var store = new Persist.Store('FeedStats'); if (store.get('resultActivity')=='true' && store.get('timeStart') !== null){ var time = new Date();//var timeDiff = time.getTime() - store.get('TS1374');var timeDiff = time.getTime() - store.get('timeStart');var timeSpent = Math.floor(timeDiff/1000);var feedStats = new ACFeedStatistics();// Fix for if (timeDiff iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issues Products Affected

iTunes 7 for Windows, iTunes 8 for Windows, Microsoft Windows XP SP2, Vista and 7

Symptoms

Learn some additional steps to troubleshoot burning issues.

Using iTunes for Windows, you can easily "burn" audio, data, and MP3 CDs with most major disc drives, including:

CD-R CD-RW DVD-R/RW DVD+R/RW

Here are a few tips you can try to solve common issues burning discs with iTunes for Windows.

Download and install the latest version of iTunes. See "Can't burn a CD in iTunes for Windows" for basic troubleshooting steps. If you continue to have difficulty, then continue with the additional troubleshooting steps below. Resolution

If after following the instructions in this document you still can't read or burn discs, try the following:

Try other software Open a different music player, such as Windows Media Player, and test if it can play a CD you've burned. Open the CD burning software that came with your computer or disc drive, and test to see if it can burn a CD.

If you're not able to read or burn discs using other software, there may be a more general issue with your computer or the drive. You should probably contact your computer or drive manufacturer for help. In the mean time, try the tips below.

Use good blank discs

Some brands of blank discs may work better with your drive than others. Check the disc manufacturer's website for the brand of blank discs you are using. Many brands post lists of drives that have issues burning to their discs. They may also publish tips on how to troubleshoot burning issues.

You can use the chart below as a general guideline to assess what types of CD-R media are compatible with different drive types.

Drive Type Drive Type Logo CD-RW Speed Range Media Type Supported Multi Speed Drive 1x ~ 4x Multi Speed CD-RW media High Speed Drive 4x ~ 16x Multi Speed CD-RW media
High Speed CD-RW media Ultra Speed Drive 16x ~ 24x Multi Speed CD-RW media
High Speed CD-RW media
Ultra Speed CD-RW media

 

Check for software updates

Microsoft or your computer's manufacturer may have released updated software. Check to see if there are updates to Windows or to the software that controls the drive. Check your computer manufacturer's website for updates, particularly for updates to the CD or DVD drive. If you bought the drive separately from the computer, check the drive manufacturer's website. See this document for additional information on updating software for Windows.

Check for firmware updates

From time to time manufacturers publish updates to a CD or DVD drive's internal software (known as firmware). Check your computer manufacturer's website for firmware updates first. This is important because the internal drives used by some companies (including Dell) require special firmware. If an update is not available from the computer manufacturer, check with the company that made the drive.

Updating your drive's firmware is a particularly good troubleshooting step if iTunes is showing a 2122, 2123, or 2131 error when trying to burn a CD. For optical drives manufactured by Aopen, firmware updates can be downloaded at http://download.aopen.com.tw/.

Important: Use special care when installing firmware updates. Incorrectly installing a firmware update could damage the drive and make it unusable. Always check with the computer manufacturer first before checking with the drive manufacturer.

Tip: If you need help with the next two steps, contact the company that manufactured your computer or drive.

Check hardware configuration

Check if your computer's drive is capable of Direct Memory Access (DMA). If so, turn on that feature and make sure the drive is not set to use Programmed Input Output (PIO). DMA and PIO are two ways a drive can be configured to connect and transfer data to a computer. PIO is the slower method. This could affect the drive's performance. If you have two drives, make sure the other drive is not using PIO either. It could affect the drive you are trying to use with iTunes. Check with the computer or drive manufacturer for additional information.

To turn on DMA:

Open Device Manager (right-click on My Computer (Windows XP and Windows 2000) or Computer (Windows Vista and Windows 7) and in the shortcut menu, click Manage) Select Device Manager. Click the plus sign, or arrow, next to IDE ATA/ATAPI controllers.

Right-click on the IDE bus that contains the optical drive and in the shortcut menu, click Properties. Click the Advanced Settings tab.
Make sure the Transfer Mode for the devices on the bus is set to DMA if available, not PIO Only.

Check drive audio cable

Some internal drives (such as the MediaStor CD-R/RW 52x24x52x) have a 2- to 4-pin analog audio cable that must be plugged into the main motherboard. This is in addition to the wider 40- to 80-pin ATA or IDE cable that connects the drive to the logic board. If the analog audio cable is not plugged in, the drive can behave in erratic ways.

Remove iPod and test

If you connect your iPod to the computer via USB and you use a USB burner, try ejecting and disconnecting iPod before trying to burn.

Additional InformationA note about copyrightiTunes software may be used to reproduce materials. It is licensed to you only for reproduction of non-copyrighted materials, materials in which you own the copyright, or materials you are authorized or legally permitted to reproduce. If you are uncertain about your right to copy any material, you should contact your legal advisor. See the iTunes Store Terms of Service for additional information.

$('articlecontent').select('img').each(function(element) { if(element.width > 640 ){ var imageDiv = document.createElement('div'); imageDiv.setStyle({ 'display':'block', 'width':'660px', 'overflow':'auto', 'border':'1px solid #dedede','margin-right': '15px'}); element.parentNode.replaceChild(imageDiv, element); imageDiv.appendChild(element); } }); $('articlecontent').select('table').each(function(element) { if(element.width > 660 || element.offsetWidth>660){ var tableDiv = document.createElement('div'); tableDiv.setAttribute("class","kbtablecontainer"); element.setAttribute("style","margin-bottom:0px !important"); element.parentNode.replaceChild(tableDiv, element); tableDiv.appendChild(element); } }); Important: Mention of third-party websites and products is for informational purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation. Apple assumes no responsibility with regard to the selection, performance or use of information or products found at third-party websites. Apple provides this only as a convenience to our users. Apple has not tested the information found on these sites and makes no representations regarding its accuracy or reliability. There are risks inherent in the use of any information or products found on the Internet, and Apple assumes no responsibility in this regard. Please understand that a third-party site is independent from Apple and that Apple has no control over the content on that website. Please contact the vendor for additional information. Rate this article:Not helpfulSomewhat helpfulHelpfulVery helpfulSolved my problemOne Moment PleaseThanks for rating this article Not helpful Somewhat helpful Helpful Very helpful Solved my problem Share this article Twitter Facebook Last Modified: May 6, 2013 Article: TS1374 Views: 1191837 Rating: 2.0/5 Stars
(2398 Responses) LanguagesCeštinaDanskDeutschEnglishEspañolSuomiFrançaisMagyarBahasa IndonesiaItaliano??????NederlandsNorsk BokmålPolskiPortuguês (Brasil)PortuguêsP??????Svenska???Türkçe???????? KmLoader.isOmnitureSupported='true'; Event.observe(window, 'load', function() { new KmLoader('2', 0, 0, 'iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issues', 0, 0, 'en_US', 0, 0, 'support_site.related_articles.TS1374',undefined,undefined,'TS1374');}); Event.observe(window, 'load', function() { new KmLoader('1', 0, 0, 'iTunes for Windows: Additional troubleshooting tips for burning issues', 0, 0, 'en_US', 0, 0, 'support_site.related_discussions.TS1374'); }); Related Discussions More discussions Related Articles Ask other users about this articlein Apple Support Communities Wait... See all questions on this articleSee all questions I have asked

View the original article here